With the 2023 NFL regular season in the books, it’s time for you, Awful Announcing’s readers, to grade the NFL’s broadcasters for this season.
In case you’re new here, this is how it works. A grade of A is the best, F is the worst, and the other three grades fall in between. This isn’t rocket science. Once all the votes have been cast, we’ll tally up the final ratings for each crew (with a score of 4 being assigned to an A, 3 to a B, and so on, down to a 0 for F) and assign a final grade.
If you missed the 2018, 2019, 2020, or 2022 rankings, click those links to check them out.
Here are the caveats for this year’s rankings.
- A team will need to work at least four games together this season to be included (though I allowed NFL Network some leeway).
- Each broadcaster will only be included once.
- National radio, Spanish language, and alternate broadcast crews (ManningCast, Dude Perfect, etc) will not be included.
- Remember, you’re voting on the crew as a whole. If you like the play-by-play broadcaster but hate the analyst (or vice versa), grade accordingly.
Polls will be open through 10 p.m. ET/7 p.m. PT on Friday, January 12th, and the rankings will be released sometime during the day on Monday, January 15th.
Broadcast teams are listed alphabetically by network (CBS, ESPN, Fox, NFL Network, and Prime Video, in that order) and alphabetically by play-by-play broadcaster within each network.
You can vote on the embedded Google Form below for as few or as many teams as you like. Thanks for voting!

About Joe Lucia
I hate your favorite team. I also sort of hate most of my favorite teams.
Recent Posts
John Strong mistakes Matt Damon for Brad Pitt on Fox World Cup final broadcast
"Brad Pitt also among the fans here."
Fox may have already lost its World Cup breakout star in Zlatan Ibrahimović
"This is also my farewell to the studio. This was the first and last time for me, so take care, everybody."
Listen: Fox, Telemundo, La 1 calls of Spain winning the World Cup
Announcing calls from broadcasts of Spain winning the 2026 FIFA World Cup final.
Alexi Lalas says ‘there is no Messi without Ronaldo,’ draws strong reaction
"You can boo Ronaldo all you want out there, because I know I heard you out there, but there is no Messi without Ronaldo."
News
Handicapping 2030 World Cup media rights: Who is likely to land the next tournament?
Wayne Rooney on FIFA World Cup final halftime show: ‘I thought it was crap’
"I like a lot of them artists, but I thought it was crap."