With Cris Collinsworth enjoying the remainder of the holiday weekend, NBC’s Sunday Night Football booth had a new voice, with Jason Garrett joining play-by-play man Mike Tirico in the booth for the Week 12 matchup between the Los Angeles Chargers and Baltimore Ravens.
"Cris Collinsworth enjoying the rest of the Thanksgiving weekend with his family."- Mike Tirico
Jason Garrett is filling in for Collinsworth in the SNF booth. 🏈📺🎙️ pic.twitter.com/JqcE7C6C9g
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 27, 2023
And while the largely lackluster 20-10 Ravens victory didn’t give the broadcast booth much to work with, the reviews for Garrett’s performance were mostly mixed, with his detractors pointing to the former Dallas Cowboys head coach’s reliance on clichés and a couple of awkward moments.
Tirico is going for a dramatic outro and Jason Garrett just does this 💀 pic.twitter.com/xbv8STvqsr
— Grant Bilse (@WiscoGrant) November 27, 2023
Jason Garrett is determined to break the Sunday night cliche record tonight. I talked to him before the game, he’s hitting on all cylinders, he’s making it hard on the defense right now.
— Bill Simmons (@BillSimmons) November 27, 2023
I didn't know how much I needed Cris Collinsworth in my life until they stuck Jason Garrett in the booth.
— Rob Pizzola (@robpizzola) November 27, 2023
jason garrett dropping a "maria looks great, doesn't she?" and tirico just openly avoiding a response just made me laugh and retch at the same time
— Ken LaVicka (@KLV1063) November 27, 2023
Damn Jason Garrett worse than Cris Collinsworth… pic.twitter.com/pS8obwI47q
— 🏁 (@LetMeSpinCoach) November 27, 2023
Who let Jason Garrett in the commentary booth???
Respectfully, he’s doing an awful job
— Luke Sawhook 🪚🪝 (@lukesawhook) November 27, 2023
Meanwhile, others seemed to enjoy Garrett’s commentary, with the 57-year-old receiving particular praise for his ability to explain what was happening on the field and his unique references.
Jason Garrett with the Ultimate Frisbee / pivot foot reference on the Sunday night broadcast.
Love it. @USAUltimate @theAUDL @PremierUltimate pic.twitter.com/xpJwqDIbDY
— Adam Zagoria (@AdamZagoria) November 27, 2023
It looks like I’m in the minority but I like Jason Garrett in this spot.
— Ryan Glasspiegel (@sportsrapport) November 27, 2023
I am….enjoying Jason Garrett on the telecast
— Clinton Yates (@clintonyates) November 27, 2023
Jason Garrett is SO much better than Cris Collinsworth because he explaining what the players, and offense/defense are doing. He's teaching.
— Sergeant–Sarge for Short (@SergeantMartee) November 27, 2023
Jason Garrett just referenced former Pirates reliever Kent Tekulve after watching Lamar Jackson submarine a throw against the Chargers.
— Gerry Dulac (@gerrydulac) November 27, 2023
It’s not necessarily surprising that Garrett — or any fill-in analyst — would receive mixed reviews while joining a play-by-play commentator he has yet to build chemistry with. For all of the criticisms — fair or not — of Collinsworth, fans have become accustomed to hearing him and Tirico call games together on Sunday nights and changing that dynamic is sure to elicit at least some sort of negative reaction as viewers adjust.
While Garrett — who has been a polarizing presence on NBC’s Notre Dame broadcasts — had some awkward, albeit largely harmless, moments, he did an adequate job calling the game and his unique references were a breath of fresh air. All things considered, it would be tough to argue that the 2016 NFL Coach of the Year carries the cache or is polished enough as a broadcaster to be in the booth for one of the league’s weekly primetime games. But as a one-week fill-in? He did just fine.
Plus, if nothing else, spending a Sunday night breaking down Garrett’s performance provided a trip down memory lane to his nine-year tenure as the Cowboys’ head coach from 2011-2019.
