Tony Dungy may no longer be a Pro Football Hall of Fame voter, but he’s still staying silent about whether he voted for the candidacy of Bill Belichick or not.
The former legendary coach and NBC analyst was one of the many big names purged from the voting list from the Hall of Fame earlier this fall when the institution narrowed its 50 person committee down to just 28 individuals. Dungy himself was inducted into the Hall in 2016 for his coaching career. He became the first African-American head coach to win a Super Bowl with the Indianapolis Colts and had a successful career with them and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Dungy’s main rival during his Colts years was Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots, who often got the best of the matchups, especially in the postseason. However, Belichick was not elected in his first year of eligibility by the Hall of Fame in spite of his record of six Lombardi Trophies.
In an appearance with Sage Steele on her podcast, Dungy was asked by the former SportsCenter anchor turned conservative media personality why he has been silent on the issue. Dungy would neither confirm nor deny his own, personal vote for Belichick, but instead reflected on the group’s decision as a whole.
Why Tony Dungy Won’t Reveal His Bill Belichick HOF Vote
@TonyDungy https://t.co/1DzwxkImts
— Sage Steele (@sagesteele) October 13, 2026
“Because I wouldn’t talk about it, and I haven’t talked about it, and I’m not going to. Everybody thinks Bill should have gotten in. There were 50 people that voted. And that’s the process and I’ve always said I stood with the voters. That’s how we voted under the rules that we had. And again, those same votes, had it been under the old rules, he would’ve gotten in. So I look at it and say, I don’t know why everybody is looking at the voters,” Dungy said.
In an interesting addendum, Tony Dungy added that he feels Bill Belichick will get into Canton, noting that Vince Lombardi didn’t get in on the first ballot either. And that whenever he does gain induction, it won’t matter on what try it was.
“I think he’ll get in. I know everybody made a big thing about the first ballot. Well, Vince Lombardi didn’t get in on the first ballot. Being a Hall of Famer, I can tell you that it doesn’t matter if you go in on the first ballot or not. Once you get in, you feel good about the process.”
Maybe it won’t make a huge amount of difference many years from now, but there is always a special distinction of being a first-ballot Hall of Famer. And no coach in any sport is probably more deserving of that accolade than Bill Belichick. But we may never know if it was media grudges or former rivals that prevent him from earning that distinction.

About Matt Yoder
Matt writes the Awful Announcing 'The A Block' newsletter every Wednesday. Subscribe here.
Recent Posts
News
Dianna Russini wants us to pretend none of this ever happened
SEC commissioner Greg Sankey fires back at Big Ten coaches’ criticism
"Let's not run to the microphone at a press conference and complain."
Paul Pierce launches new live show with former ‘Gil’s Arena’ cast members
Pierce will be flanked by Rashad McCants and Brandon Jennings on a new weekly live show, 'Truth Hurts.'
Cam Newton launching ‘4th & 1 Presents: Quarterback Club’ series on Amazon Prime
“Quarterback Club is the room where we can finally be honest."
TV and streaming viewing picks for November 10, 2026: How to watch Champions Classic
Four college basketball blue blood programs face off in the Champions Classic at the United Center in Chicago on ESPN tonight.
Sports media world appalled by Carson Wentz’s awful play
This was an absolute disaster.