What began as a shoutout for Greg Olsen, resulted in Erin Andrews revealing her love for America’s greatest sandwich, peanut butter and jelly.
During the latest episode of Calm Down With Erin and Charissa, Andrews chided the viral photo of Olsen appearing as if he had a few adult beverages at the recent wedding between San Francisco 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey and model Olivia Culpo. The shoutout prompted Thompson to recall Olsen previously appearing on their Calm Down podcast with a bucket hat. Olsen explained that he puts the hat on as soon as he and his family arrives to their vacation home. He was on vacation at the time of the interview, thus the appearance of his vacation hat.
Thompson then shared her affinity for traditions, suggesting everyone incorporate more of them in their lives, which opened the door for the appearance of the peanut butter and jelly sandwich.
“I have a peanut butter and jelly sandwich before every game, is that a tradition?” Andrews asked. “I feel like it just gives me energy.”
If you poll NFL audiences on what Erin Andrews does prior to every broadcast, the odds of them coming up with “eat a peanut butter and jelly sandwich” seems unlikely.
But Andrews is not alone in her appreciation for peanut butter and jelly. Recently, Stephen A. Smith offered one of the best takes of his career, hitting peanut butter and jelly with the nod of “best sandwich of all time.”
And it deserves that nod, because few things are more dependable than a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It contains protein, it’s filling, satisfying, salty, sweet, quick, and almost always readily available. When all else fails, peanut butter and jelly is always there. And for Erin Andrews, it’s there before every NFL broadcast.

About Brandon Contes
Brandon Contes is a staff writer for Awful Announcing and The Comeback. He previously helped carve the sports vertical for Mediaite and spent more than three years with Barrett Sports Media. Send tips/comments/complaints to bcontes@thecomeback.com
Recent Posts
Over 60,000 Washington Post readers reportedly canceled their subscriptions following mass layoffs
The Post disputed that figure but declined to provide an alternate number.
CBS, ESPN, Fox all notch strong college basketball viewership for 2025-26 season
Regular season college basketball reached new viewership highs in the 2025-26 season, with blue bloods like Duke, Michigan State, and North Carolina leading the way.
The sports media dreams of college football All-22 film
"This is the bane of our existence."
Bill Simmons says the Washington Wizards are ‘bastardizing the game’
"There's 30 NBA teams. You're all professional athletes. You're all getting paid. F---ing stop the guy! Don't whine about it."
PWHL getting first U.S. national TV broadcast on March 28 with Ion
"We just felt in the last couple of weeks like the PWHL is having a moment and we’ll see what kind of traction they build off of this."
NFL now selling Australia game as part of a package in media rights renegotiations
"Multiple sources have told me the NFL will now roll the rights to that Australia game into a package with four or five other games."