Adam Schefter Marvin Harrison Jr Credit: Darren Yamashita – Imagn Images; Kirby Lee – Imagn Images

Less AI and more AA in your search results.

Add Awful Announcing as a preferred source on Google

Early Saturday, ESPN senior NFL insider Adam Schefter dropped his latest bombshell: the Arizona Cardinals were trading the No. 4 overall pick from the 2024 draft, wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr.

The son of a Hall of Fame wideout, Harrison was seen as a surefire prospect coming out of Ohio State. He was the first receiver selected in a loaded draft that also included Malik Nabers, Rome Odunze, Brian Thomas Jr. and Ladd McConkey.

Harrison’s future in Arizona dissolved quickly over the course of the last season-plus, and the Cardinals’ new coaching staff had reportedly soured on him. The team apparently has pulled the trigger on a deal a full month before the trade deadline.

Schefter’s posts on X breaking the story, however, lacked one significant detail: Harrison’s destination.

“The team informed Harrison this morning that he will be inactive for Sunday’s game vs Detroit as details of the trade are finalized,” Schefter wrote.

A later post added:

“The one certainty is that Marvin Harrison’s time in Arizona is done. Arizona feels comfortable enough to know it can and will trade Harrison, which is why he will be inactive Sunday. But no Harrison trade will be completed until after Sunday’s games are played.”

Rival reporters soon filled in the gaps. Pro Football Talk’s Mike Florio quickly shared that Harrison was likely headed to the Houston Texans, which was confirmed by Jonathan Jones of The Athletic, whose Indianapolis Colts beat writer James Boyd added the Colts were not trading for Harrison. Later Saturday, Schefter and Ian Rapoport confirmed that the Texans were the most likely trade partner for Arizona, reuniting Harrison with his Ohio State QB, C.J. Stroud.

As details trickled in, NFL fans were shocked by Schefter’s open-ended reporting. Jokes gave way to the realization that Schefter was, effectively, opening a bidding war for the underperforming young receiver. Further updates indicated Arizona seemed to have an offer in hand of a second-round pick, but may have believed it could get more for Harrison.

Schefter’s commentary became more bizarre when he shared a post from a former NFL coach speculated that the Cardinals were making the trade public in order to juice the market.

“A plausible theory,” Schefter wrote as a caption for the post.

Within hours of Schefter’s initial scoop, ESPN’s Cardinals beat reporter Josh Weinfuss published his own story — shared by Schefter — on the situation. Weinfuss confirmed that Houston was the front-runner, and that the asking price was a second-round pick “and more,” but that the Cardinals believed Harrison’s value was closer to a first-round selection.

Weinfuss notably also included more of Harrison’s perspective, writing that Harrison had recently hired agents for the first time in his career, likely with the intention of having them help him navigate a trade. The Weinfuss story also addressed why the Cardinals might be trading Harrison so early, explaining that inquiring teams likely wanted as much time as possible to evaluate the underperforming top-five pick before they make a decision on the fifth-year option in his contract.

By Sunday morning, Theo Mackie, who covers the Cardinals for the Arizona Republic, was out with a story providing more context for Harrison’s time in Arizona — including a viral anecdote about how the Cardinals were unwilling to pay $50,000 to upgrade the team’s Seeker training equipment.

Across social media fans, voiced their frustration with Schefter.

“I can’t stand Adam Schefter bro. Give us the team he’s going to no one gives a sh*t if you’re first,” read the top comment on the story in the NFL Reddit community.

Local reporters will always have more unique insights into the teams they cover. Schefter likely knew Weinfuss would quickly add more context to the Harrison situation. Still, the question that fans rightly asked after Schefter’s open-ended post on X gave way to actual details from others is why Schefter reported the incomplete story at all.

Shortly after the publication of this story, Texans head coach DeMeco Ryans revealed in a press conference that the team had acquired Harrison for a second-round pick. The unusual timeline and reporting around the teams’ talks led to the rare trade announcement by a head coach.

Much of Schefter’s job revolves around simply being first with information. He accomplished that with the Harrison news. But he did very little to actually explain what was going on, arguably leaving readers more confused than if he had shared nothing.

The actual effect of how Schefter handled the story will be revealed in due time, depending on what Arizona can recoup for Harrison. Even if his vague, market-setting scoop does not materially change the parameters of the deal, Schefter has once again shown fans that his goal is not necessarily to tell the full story, but to guarantee the news cycle is built around him.

About Brendon Kleen

Brendon is an Editorial Lead at Awful Announcing overseeing digital content and special projects. He lives in Phoenix and has covered sports media for Awful Announcing since 2023.

Brendon writes the Awful Announcing 'The A Block' newsletter every Monday Subscribe here.