Aaron Rodgers loves to entertain conspiracy theories, but apparently, he doesn’t like to be part of one.
Last week, Billy Gil of The Dan Le Batard Show with Stugotz casually posed the theory that Rodgers never actually ruptured his Achilles based on the quarterback recovering at from the injury at a seemingly historic pace. That theory created a social media firestorm, making its way to Colin Cowherd, and apparently, even Aaron Rodgers.
Tuesday afternoon, Rodgers made his weekly appearance on The Pat McAfee Show, and sounded displeased with the idea of people questioning his injury.
“I have some very interesting thoughts that ESPN would probably try and cut off the broadcast if I started really getting into how I feel about that stuff.” Aaron Rodgers on conspiracy theories about his torn Achilles pic.twitter.com/5Bum6ncO9W
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 14, 2023
“I have some very interesting thoughts that ESPN would probably try and cut off the broadcast if I started really getting into how I feel about that stuff,” Rodgers told McAfee.
During Rodgers’ Halloween appearance with McAfee, seconds after Dr. Fauci’s name was broached on the show, ESPN’s feed went dark for 12 minutes for many linear viewers. While the glitch was probably nothing more than a glitch, a conspiracy theorist might thing there was some intent behind the technical issues. It seems like we can count Rodgers among those conspiracy theorists.
So now we have Rodgers, a known conspiracy theorist, sneering at someone else’s conspiracy by evoking another conspiracy theory.
“The same people entertaining the possibility of conspiracy about my Achilles could not possibly fathom a world in which anything related to this beautiful, experimental gene therapy could have any issues with that,” Rodgers continued with his weekly reference to Covid vaccines. “Fascinating. Fascinating. So I just went into it, they probably just cut the feed. I don’t give a sh*t, I don’t give a sh*t.”
Does that mean Rodgers would be okay with someone questioning his Achilles injury as long as they also question Covid vaccines? It sounds like Rodgers took The Dan Le Batard Show entertaining this Achilles conspiracy theory to heart rather than treating it as a wild talking point on a podcast. But just in case there was any real skepticism around Rodgers’ injury, he reaffirmed that he did indeed suffer a torn Achilles four plays into the NFL season.
“It was ruptured,” Rodgers said. “It was fixed by the best doctor in the land and my entire focus from September 13th has been rehab and get back on the field.”
Rodgers will entertain conspiracies about Covid, vaccines, aliens, 9/11, Chinese spy balloons and being censored by ESPN. But The Pat McAfee Show’s resident conspiracy theorist draws the line at conspiracies about his Achilles.

About Brandon Contes
Brandon Contes is a staff writer for Awful Announcing and The Comeback. He previously helped carve the sports vertical for Mediaite and spent more than three years with Barrett Sports Media. Send tips/comments/complaints to bcontes@thecomeback.com
Recent Posts
Rockies call of Padres walk-off grand slam will leave you questioning the meaning of life
It’s not been a fun time to be a fan of the Colorado Rockies so you could only...
Erin Andrews shares story behind father’s ‘horrible’ heart attack in December
"The moral of the story is, thank God my dad is alive, but my dad is alive because of these healthcare workers..."
Here’s your 2026 MLB scorebug roundup
A look at the 2026 MLB scorebugs for each local and national broadcast.
Trey Wingo criticizes ESPN Masters coverage: ‘It doesn’t need all this hyperbolic nonsense’
"It's all the other crap, for lack of a better term, that's being shoved down golf viewers' throats that is turning people away."
Augusta National chairman admits Dude Perfect hijinks at Amen Corner wasn’t ‘best idea’
"It does point out that we try things every once in a while that are a little bit nontraditional."
‘Women’s Sports Now’ moving from Roku to ESPN, premiering April 16
"We’re continuing to expand how we serve fans of women’s sports."