With the number of Black players on Opening Day rosters reaching a record low for a third straight year, Major League Baseball has taken steps to improve its diversity.
And with the first round of the MLB Draft seemingly indicating that those efforts are paying off, one reporter took to social media to note as much — only to receive backlash for his post.
“MLB Draft: 9 of the first 21 players selected in the first round are Black players. #Diversity,” USA Today‘s Bob Nightengale posted to X after the Minnesota Twins selected Kansas State shortstop Kaelen Culpepper.
MLB Draft: 9 of the first 21 players selected in the first round are Black players. #Diversity
— Bob Nightengale (@BNightengale) July 15, 2024
While there isn’t necessarily anything wrong with the content of Nightengale’s post, many were quick to note his awkward use of #diversity, in hashtag form. Even if it’s notable that Black players comprised nearly half of the first 21 picks — and it is — the situation seemingly deserves more context than a hashtag, which was originally implemented on social media as a device to group similar posts together.
The hashtag is crazy lmfao https://t.co/7NKz22u84m
— JP Acosta (@acosta32_jp) July 15, 2024
bro he did NOT just include that hashtag 😂 https://t.co/ne8ZIS3whJ
— fank (@dfank_BU) July 15, 2024
Incredible hashtag, 5 years after hashtags were last a thing https://t.co/4GdITMXTWe
— nugget chef (@jayhaykid) July 15, 2024
Hashtag got me in tears https://t.co/YOAbt7sX2s
— Vic Damone Jr (@wholesomefoxx) July 15, 2024
Hashtag diversity is one of the funniest things I’ve ever read from a media pundit https://t.co/A8tJc1MmJf
— OriolesMuse (@OriolesMuse) July 15, 2024
it’s the hashtag for me https://t.co/H2bVbWn5Iv
— Gage (@GageEHC) July 15, 2024
Tears dude https://t.co/ggF7MX0Cyg pic.twitter.com/TENFEVe7ym
— Pranav Sriraman (@PranavSriraman) July 15, 2024
I can’t believe this is a real tweet. I’m grateful it exists though https://t.co/ApzFhCvT7s
— Josh Goldberg (@JGoldberg12) July 15, 2024
As some noted, this isn’t Nightengale’s first awkward social media post regarding diversity in the MLB Draft. Amid the George Floyd protests in 2020, the longtime USA Today reporter and columnist commemorated the Chicago Cubs’ selection of Ed Howard, who is Black, by posting, “The #Cubs draft Ed Howard, yes, showing action instead of hallow words.
The Céspedes Family BBQ account called back to Nightengale’s since-deleted tweet following Sunday’s post.
Action instead of hallow words https://t.co/85CL4gSN2G
— Céspedes Family BBQ (@CespedesBBQ) July 15, 2024
Unlike his post about Howard — which many took as Nightengale implying that his race played a role in the Cubs drafting him — there wasn’t anything wrong, per se, about his post on Sunday. It was just awkward. Considering that making the post without the hashtag might have also led to some uncomfortable replies, the best solution like would have been to include more context as to why the number of Black players selected on Sunday was significant in the larger context of MLB’s recent diversity issues.
Ultimately, the reality of social media is that even if there wasn’t anything malicious about Nightengale’s intent, there’s a reason why his post was received similarly by so many people. And considering it came five years after his post regarding Howard and his previous social media mishaps, the reaction was hardly surprising.