I recognize this is my third post about St. Louis Cardinals analyst Jim Edmonds in the last week, but I promise there are no ill intentions. The recent attention is his own doing.
During the Cardinals’ Tuesday night game on Bally Sports Midwest against the Miami Marlins, Edmonds attempted some combination of a joke and an analogy that left play-by-play voice Dan McLaughlin, and probably much of the viewing audience, very confused.
After Albert Pujols hit a slow dribbler down the first base line for a groundout, Edmonds and McLaughlin both commented about it being frustrating for a DH to have to wait an hour for their next opportunity. And that’s when Edmonds decided to steal the show.
“That’s like, you know, when you, you know, you read things for so long and you just throw out like the name of our old TV station verses our new one or, you know, stuff like that,” Edmonds said. “Just kinda flies out and you just don’t even realize it.”
What?
https://twitter.com/BrandonContes/status/1542138878215208960
“Jimmy, I gotta tell ya, I have no idea what you’re talking about,” McLaughlin hilariously responded.
Thank goodness for McLaughlin’s honesty, and credit him for not just playing along. Because as the audience was sitting at home scratching their heads, they all surely celebrated when McLaughlin asked for clarification on what the heck Edmonds just tried to say.
“No, I’m saying like, you know, sometimes I’ll start to talk and forget where we’re at with the Bally’s and Fox and Fox Sports Midwest, Fox Sports, Bally’s, Live Midwest, sometimes it just kinda comes out wrong,” Edmonds – clarified? “It’s just like the spinning ball, you never know where it’s gonna go.”
From what I can gather, Edmonds was trying to say that you never know what network name will come out of a broadcaster’s mouth, the same way you never know where a slow dribbler is going to go off of Pujols’ bat.
Coming out of the previous break, McLaughlin said Fox Sports Midwest instead of Bally Sports Midwest. Determined to make a joke about the mistake, Edmonds attempted to use Pujols’ groundout as a segue. Not only did the joke not land, it left everyone dumbfounded.

About Brandon Contes
Brandon Contes is a staff writer for Awful Announcing and The Comeback. He previously helped carve the sports vertical for Mediaite and spent more than three years with Barrett Sports Media. Send tips/comments/complaints to bcontes@thecomeback.com
Recent Posts
Steelers legend Terry Bradshaw says he’s never met Mike Tomlin
"Maybe everybody'll leave you alone and respect you for what you've accomplished in the great city of Pittsburgh."
How will Netflix Warner Bros. deal affect sports documentaries?
This acquisition makes it hard to be optimistic about the future of sports documentaries.
TV and streaming viewing picks for December 8, 2025: How to watch Eagles-Chargers
Week 14 in the NFL ends in Inglewood, CA as the Eagles hope to right their ship against the Los Angeles Chargers. ESPN2 has a Monsters, Inc altcast.
Dave Portnoy apoplectic over Raiders bad beat: ‘Pete Carroll should be in f**king prison’
"That's the worst beat of all time! That is cheating! What the f**k?!?"
Fox’s Brady Quinn calls out ESPN over Notre Dame bowl withdrawal criticism
Quinn was not having the perceived double standard...
Aaron Rodgers hopes Steelers win means media ‘will shut the hell up for a week’ about Mike Tomlin
Rodgers may get his wish, but more complaints are just one loss away...