Now that Around the Horn is ending this week, longtime host Tony Reali is finally spilling the beans on everything related to the show’s storied history.
In his latest interview during the show’s wind-down, Reali joined Stupodity with Jon “Stugotz” Weiner and revealed his Mt. Rushmore of ATH panelists. Reali also detailed his criteria in depth, given that he has long refrained from picking favorites.
“My Mt. Rushmore is who would literally survive on Mt. Rushmore,” Reali explained. “Who are the last four surviving debaters? We’re talking about endurance. We’re talking about expert analytical argument. We’re talking about the will to do what the other people won’t, in a sports debate.”
The list:
- Bob Ryan
- Woody Paige
- Sarah Spain
- Bomani Jones
Ryan because he best represents the antagonistic spirit of the show; Paige because he is most synonymous with the show; Spain because she was the most fearless; and Jones because he, according to Reali, has never really lost.
“He’s never really lost a sports debate, he’s just allowed it to end,” Reali said of the former Highly Questionable and High Noon host.
For anyone who believed Reali had never thought of his top ATHers or allowed himself to imagine his own Mt. Rushmore, think again. Of course, the man who runs the controls did not defer to points totals or winning percentage with his picks. This is an art, not a science.
Last year, Awful Announcing’s list leaned far more toward the old school. Our top four were Tim Cowlishaw, Woody Paige, J.A. Adande, and Jackie MacMullan.
If the response to that piece is any indication, Tony Reali will be hearing from the many other past and current panelists about his list.

About Brendon Kleen
Brendon is a Media Commentary staff writer at Awful Announcing. He has also covered basketball and sports business at Front Office Sports, SB Nation, Uproxx and more.
Recent Posts
Dave Portnoy apoplectic over Raiders bad beat: ‘Pete Carroll should be in f**king prison’
"That's the worst beat of all time! That is cheating! What the f**k?!?"
Fox’s Brady Quinn calls out ESPN over Notre Dame bowl withdrawal criticism
Quinn was not having the perceived double standard...
Aaron Rodgers hopes Steelers win means media ‘will shut the hell up for a week’ about Mike Tomlin
Rodgers may get his wish, but more complaints are just one loss away...
ESPN reveals announcers for 2025-26 College Football Playoff
The CFP begins on Friday, Dec. 19, at 8 p.m. ET on ABC and ESPN with No. 9 Alabama at No. 8 Oklahoma.
Despite criticism, CFP chair Hunter Yurachek doesn’t see need to change weekly ranking shows
"You're always going to have controversy, and that's why we debated for so long..."
It’s inevitable that the college football bowl system will die
Blame it on whatever you want, college football and it's power brokers have already started killing the bowl system.