Stephen A. Smith came to Bart Scott’s defense after the ESPN NFL analyst had a brutal take on the collision that caused Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin to collapse on the field Monday night.
After tackling Cincinnati Bengals wide receiver Tee Higgins Monday night, Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin stood up before quickly collapsing, going into cardiac arrest and requiring his heartbeat to be restored on the field. Hamlin has been in critical condition, but Thursday morning, the Bills shared an optimistic update from doctors stating the NFL safety has shown “remarkable improvement.”
While most analysts viewed the hit as a routine football play, Scott appeared to direct some blame at Higgins for lowering his helmet into Hamlin during the collision. Scott made the analysis on ESPN’s First Take and has since been blasted by fans and players, prompting Smith to offer defense.
Stephen A. Smith defends Bart Scott from criticism over his Damar Hamlin-Tee Higgins take pic.twitter.com/1hXVeWSDDA
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) January 5, 2023
“Let me look into the camera and tell these folks in America to ‘calm down’ as it pertains to Bart Scott,” Smith said on First Take. “People are walking around acting like Bart Scott, in his explanation of the play that ended up injuring Hamlin, that Bart Scott was alluding to Tee Higgins doing something like that on purpose. He did no such thing. That is not true. That is a lie. OK? Nobody would be that insensitive for crying out loud. Especially somebody like Bart Scott. That is false.”
Smith noted that he asked Scott to break down what happened on the play to create the contact between Higgins and Hamlin. Below is video of Scott’s response to the question which garnered criticism.
Bart Scott is on ESPN actually blaming Tee Higgins for "lowering his helmet" into the player. Which did not happen.
Dude has a weird vendetta against the Bengals but this is taking it too far.
— Faux Joey Brrr (@FauxJeaux) January 3, 2023
“He wasn’t blaming Tee Higgins in anyway,” Smith said of Scott. “He wasn’t questioning his intent in anyway, and for people out there to say otherwise is ludicrous. That is not what Bart Scott said on this show yesterday, that’s an absolute lie.”
Scott wasn’t questioning Higgins’ intent, but by saying he “throws his body into (Hamlin’s) chest,” it certainly appeared as though the ESPN analyst was placing at least some blame on the wide receiver for what ended up being a near fatal collision. And after Higgins was clearly distraught by the collision that left Hamlin in critical condition, Scott’s accusatory spin on the routine football play was reckless.

About Brandon Contes
Brandon Contes is a staff writer for Awful Announcing and The Comeback. He previously helped carve the sports vertical for Mediaite and spent more than three years with Barrett Sports Media. Send tips/comments/complaints to bcontes@thecomeback.com
Recent Posts
TV and streaming viewing picks for August 18, 2026: How to watch Hard Knocks
The latest episode of Hard Knocks: Training Camp with the Seattle Seahawks premieres tonight on HBO and HBO Max.
Pat McAfee refutes fabricated claim he’s taking over Lee Corso’s headgear picks on ‘College GameDay’
"I have come to a fun chapter where folks just make stuff up to make me look like a bigger a**hole."
Sports media world reacts to death of Ravens legend O.J. Brigance
"This is a tremendously sad day for Baltimore."
Dan Orlovsky eats cold chicken as replacement birthday cake on ‘NFL Live’
"That's actually pretty good. I don't understand why people hate."
Elle Duncan: ‘Right now, the WNBA is the most toxic space to cover’
"...I think we are wasting [the moment] by muddying it down with everything else that's bothering us in this country right now."
Luke Kuechly reportedly replacing Bill Belichick on Peyton Manning’s ‘The Breakdown’
Kuechly is clearly the hottest name in NFL broadcasting right now.