It’s another year of College Football Playoff rankings being unveiled on a weekly basis and another year of those rankings being torn apart for being entirely incoherent, irrational, and illogical.
ESPN debuted the 2026 CFP rankings on the first Tuesday in November, which also happened to be the night of midterm elections. It was probably best for the committee and the sport as a whole that the rankings drew little attention, with much of the country locked in on election coverage and just how long Steve Kornacki could hold it in without having to use the restroom.
As soon as they were released, the rankings could easily be picked apart for how many holes the committee’s reasoning could be poked in. And as ESPN college football analyst and longtime voice of the South Paul Finebaum said on Get Up the morning after, it was the most “discombobulated” rankings he had ever seen.
“It is about as discombobulated a ranking as I’ve ever seen.”
@finebaum shares his thoughts on the latest CFP rankings 👀 https://t.co/fvgBwP1rQv
— Get Up (@GetUpESPN) November 4, 2026
“I don’t really know if I can make much sense out of it because it is about as discombobulated a ranking as I’ve ever seen. I would use words like the committee was drunk, but that would be inappropriate for such an august group of people, but it really doesn’t make any sense,” Finebaum said.
Where do you even begin to sort through the madness? Ohio State was ranked all the way down at #12 with a win against Indiana and a one-point road loss to Texas on their resume. Notre Dame fell to #11, and undefeated UCLA is behind multiple two-loss SEC teams at #8. And if the committee wants to lean on strength of schedule as a major factor, how is Indiana at #4 when their biggest win so far this season is at a beleaguered Michigan team in overtime?
But no team may be more befuddling than the 6-2 Alabama Crimson Tide, all the way up at #5 in the first CFP rankings, despite a double-digit loss to Tennessee, who is on the outside looking in at #13.
Even Paul Finebaum, who built his media career in the state, couldn’t believe the Tide’s good fortune. And bonus points to him for using the word “disembowled” in a football argument.
“Trying to make sense out of this would literally drive me crazy because there isn’t really a lot of sense. Even though I’m sitting in Alabama today, Alabama has no business being where they are. That is truly absurd to have Alabama that far ahead of Tennessee, a team that just disemboweled them a couple of weeks ago in Neyland Stadium,” Finebaum added.
Any time you rank teams subjectively, inconsistencies are bound to happen. But this once again proves that this entire process hurts the committee’s work and the sport as a whole. There is no reason to release rankings before the end of the season, when the committee has to be exposed weekly before the work is even done. It’d be like asking the Wright Brothers to fly their plane before they even put an engine in it.
We have seen multiple times through the years that these rankings don’t matter, and the committee can flip-flop whoever they want in the only ones that count at the end of the season. But because ESPN wants the content, we will be forced to go through this mind-numbing charade for the next several weeks.

About Matt Yoder
Matt writes the Awful Announcing 'The A Block' newsletter every Wednesday. Subscribe here.
Recent Posts
Pat McAfee showed up to ‘College GameDay’ on a horse
"I've never ridden a horse before. I certainly lied to them to let that happen."
Robert Griffin III counters Desmond Howard over Jeremiah Smith’s Heisman case: ‘Stop hating’
"Desmond Howard has to stop hating on Jeremiah Smith just because he goes to Ohio State."
Paul Finebaum eviscerates Oklahoma AD, defends SEC over Ole Miss postponement
"What he did here is really against the code of the SEC to call out a commissioner during a national crisis and emergency."
TKO CEO Ari Emanuel blames Pete Buttigieg for FAA shutdown
"You left a failing system in place. THANKS!"
‘College GameDay’ returns to Army-Navy Game for first time since 2023
College GameDay will make its tenth overall trip to cover the Army-Navy Game in December and its first in three years.
Aaron Rodgers shares heartfelt picture with Jordan Rodgers after family reconciliation
After years of not being on speaking terms, Aaron Rodgers visited brother Jordan in the ESPN broadcast booth in Pittsburgh.