On Sunday afternoon, ABC and ESPN had coverage of the highly anticipated Game 7 in the Eastern Conference Semifinals between the New York Knicks and Indiana Pacers. Except, if you watched the network’s NBA Countdown pregame coverage, you would be forgiven for thinking only one of those teams was playing.
ESPN (and much of the sports media and overall media in general) have been accused of having east coast bias for years and favoring large markets and huge brands over anyone else. It’s why the Yankees and Red Sox seemingly always play on Sunday Night Baseball, why the Cowboys are talked about ad infinitum, and why the Lakers get so many nationally televised games even when they’re not good.
But ESPN is going next level to feed this narrative by focusing a good chunk of their NBA playoffs coverage on the fact that Stephen A. Smith is a Knicks fan and openly rooting for the team live on the air.
There’s nothing wrong with Smith acknowledging his fandom, he’s more entertainer than reporter or analyst these days anyways. But for some reason, ESPN is making Smith’s Knicks fandom a centerpiece of their coverage throughout the series. The network has made Smith seemingly a star on equal footing with the best players in the series like Jalen Brunson and Tyrese Haliburton as if he’s playing in the games. Judging by conversation earlier in the week, maybe ESPN thinks he is playing!
Don’t believe us? Just watch the ABC intro and who the network showed walking into MSG on Sunday.
ESPN shows Jalen Brunson, Tyrese Haliburton, and… Stephen A. Smith (???) arriving at MSG for Knicks-Pacers Game 7. Is Stephen A. playing in the game?!? pic.twitter.com/67oD6CWh4Z
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) May 19, 2024
And then at the end of NBA Countdown, viewers at home (Knicks AND Pacers fans alike) were treated to a pep talk from Smith to his beloved New Yorkers, complete with a Spike Lee cameo where SAS got so worked up he knocked off his hat.
If that wasn’t enough, viewers also got a Stephen A. Smith pep talk directed to the Knicks, which was a bunch of shouting and knocking off Spike Lee’s hat. pic.twitter.com/cfkABz0fSF
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) May 19, 2024
ESPN’s studio coverage has been through a number of iterations over the last several years with a revolving door of hosts, analysts, and personalities. They’ve always been compared to TNT’s beloved Inside the NBA and always fallen well short. But through all the different attempts to put something competitive and quality together, this Knicks-P̶a̶c̶e̶r̶s̶ pregame show may be rock bottom.
Unless you were a diehard Knicks or Stephen A. Smith fan, you were likely changing the channel as it was completely one-sided and the basketball played second fiddle to one of the studio personalities.
Does a neutral fan go into this game with *any* idea of what is at stake for Indiana today? Honestly, I’m not sure they go into this game with any idea of what’s at stake for *New York* as ESPN only discusses the Knicks in the context of Stephen A.’s fandom.
— Sports Media Watch (@paulsen_smw) May 19, 2024
ESPN’s NBA pregame show is pretty much now almost entirely about Stephen A Smith and who he is friends with rather than the basketball about to be played.
— Sopan Deb (@SopanDeb) May 19, 2024
If ESPN is concerned about an East coast bias, having nearly the entire pregame centering around the Knicks doesn’t help.
Up next, Stephen A.’s Knicks pep talk.
— Andrew Marchand (@AndrewMarchand) May 19, 2024
ESPN showed Stephen A walking into the arena like he’s a player. Now they just teased that he’s going to give the a pregame speech for the Knicks like he’s a coach?
Serious question: do people actually find this entertaining? Like, what’s the endgame here for espn??
— Chris Joseph (@byChrisJoseph) May 19, 2024
Sports analysts have the right to root for teams just like the rest of us.
But, national analysts used to stay neutral and professional and not act like they were working for one particular team.
ESPN and Stephen A. hyping themselves up for the Knicks pregame was ridiculous.
— Josh Spicer (@joshspicer11) May 19, 2024
ABC pregame acting like they’re the Knicks pregame.
— Matthew (@ThisIsMatthew97) May 19, 2024
Pacers perspective got no run on the ESPN/ABC pregame show.
What happened to journalism and breaking down what’s at stake for both sides— Clarence Hill Jr (@clarencehilljr) May 19, 2024
Watching this pregame show you’d think the Pacers weren’t even playing.
— Ryan Kennedy (@RyanKWrites) May 19, 2024
It’s not like Inside the NBA focuses 100% on basketball, and they definitely give the latitude to let Charles Barkley, Shaquille O’Neal, and company be themselves and be entertaining. But TNT can pull it off and do so naturally while never making themselves bigger than the game.
On the other hand, if the Knicks do make it to the NBA Finals, we may Stephen A. Smith pull a Fan Man to try to force his way into the game himself.