Joe Buck and Troy Aikman Credit: Matthew Emmons-USA TODAY Sports

Less AI and more AA in your search results.

Add Awful Announcing as a preferred source on Google

A Troy Aikman-Joe Buck divorce seems inevitable.

The rest of the sports media world has been watching this drama unfold slowly with great interest, because we rarely see something like this happen in real time. Buck has his contract extension, while Aikman does not, making an already strained 25-year relationship even more fractured. When you have stars this big—a Hall of Fame quarterback and a Hall of Fame broadcaster—with egos to match, leaks are inevitable.

Recently, The Athletic’s Andrew Marchand and Puck’s Dylan Byers have reported additional details about ESPN’s feuding Monday Night Football team. From the outside, it seems both sides are trying to control the narrative. Meanwhile, ESPN hasn’t done much to resolve the situation, either by offering Aikman the deal he’s seeking, by issuing a statement supporting both sides while acknowledging they’re hopeful of reaching a contract with Aikman, or by announcing that this will be Aikman’s final season and wishing him the best.

Controversy draws attention. So, maybe ESPN is perfectly fine with the uneasy status quo. However, a ratings bump due to this scenario seems unlikely. Your average fan tunes in for the games and doesn’t care about bickering millionaire broadcasters.

Crisis management expert Jeff Hunt said that if Aikman’s time at ESPN is indeed coming to an end, it might behoove The Worldwide Leader in Sports to say so and end the public squabbling.

“I think they just sort of say, ‘Look, these things have natural cycles,’” he said. “‘We’ve had a great run with Troy and Joe Buck, but it’s kind of come to that time where we’re going to all move on and do new things. We obviously wish Aikman well, and we’re going to be excited to announce who the next part of a Joe Buck will be. We’re not ready to announce that yet, but stay tuned.’”

And what would be Hunt’s advice for Aikman?

“I think he should just be such a gentleman in the whole thing,” Hunt said. “He should just be the consummate professional. And that would be my advice to him right now. To say, ‘I’m not going to get into any weeds or discussions. I’m focused on next week’s game and the week after that and fulfilling (my contract).’ And I would, if I were Aikman, not (dwell on) his obligations to ESPN; it would be to the fans… ‘I’m there to do my job. I’m not going to speculate.’ I would take the highest road possible if I were him.”

Without definitive information, speculation will keep running rampant. Aikman might suspect Buck’s role in all of this, and he certainly has more information than the public. He may have every right to be paranoid and distrustful of Buck. But ESPN may also believe this relationship has run its course and no longer wants to pay Aikman a high salary.

If you’ve ever been laid off or not had your contract renewed, it may have nothing to do with your performance. Businesses often choose not to retain employees for reasons that only seem to make sense to them. If we were in a high-profile job, many of us might also be motivated to leak stuff to the media.

While we’re seeing a lot of dirty laundry aired, with Buck and Aikman’s camps pointing fingers at each other, there could be a simpler reason behind this breakup.

What if ESPN wanted new blood in the broadcast booth and thought that it would be easier to replace Aikman with a fresh face?

“I think there could be a shelf life on the celebrity complement to the team,” Hunt said. “So they could also just be looking to get someone younger to get younger audiences in. Younger, fresher, just left the game.

He added: “Players come, players go. And so, I think keeping the player part of the duo fresh could be one of the motivations… and you’ve got some interesting people that are coming in.”

About Michael Grant

Born in Jamaica. Grew up in New York City. Lives in Louisville, Ky. Sports writer. Not related to Ulysses S. Grant.