Arch manning Paul Finebaum Credit: Kevin Jairaj – Imagn Images; The Matt Barrie Show

Less AI and more AA in your search results.

Add Awful Announcing as a preferred source on Google

Heading into Arch Manning’s freshman season at Texas, ESPN’s Paul Finebaum was driving the bandwagon.

The longtime college football commentator crowned the young quarterback as the preseason favorite for the Heisman and hailed him as the next generational prospect for the NFL. Within weeks, Finebaum had to backpedal. Manning played poorly to open the 2025 season against Ohio State, and the Longhorns’ College Football Playoff hopes effectively died when he turned the ball over twice in a midseason loss to Florida.

While some film junkies still hyped Manning up as an NFL prospect and broadcasters attempted to mount a late-season Heisman push, the attention around the youngster began to feel largely propped up by his family name.

When Manning led a miracle comeback at home against Ohio State last month, the coronation appeared to be back on. The Longhorns rode a No. 1 ranking through early season until Week 6, when they lost to Oklahoma in the annual Red River Rivalry game. Manning threw two late-game interceptions that sealed the upset loss.

Finebaum again led the conversation around Manning, though this time the “Mouth of the South” had nothing complimentary to say about the QB.

“We showed arrogance in believing that Arch Manning can do anything. And he almost did, except he finally got in the way of himself,” Finebaum said Sunday morning on The Matt Barrie Show, referencing Texas’ late charge against Oklahoma.

“And I was really troubled by how he had played up to this point. I came away thinking, I don’t know what this guy’s going to do. Because he is not the elite player that we all tried to make him out to be. He can be great in moments, as we saw near the end of the game, as he threw that great play that set up the touchdown, but he can just be downright stupid in others.”

The rollercoaster of Finebaum’s commentary on Manning shows how the ESPN personality operates. Finebaum epitomizes the idea that the media loves to tear down those it had previously built up. The answer is likely somewhere in the middle. Manning may still have the physical ability to excel as a quarterback in the NFL, but he hasn’t delivered on the promise with which he arrived in Austin, Texas.

The Longhorns’ championship aspirations and Manning’s draft stock took a big hit this week, and Finebaum isn’t about to let himself fall behind the narrative again.

About Brendon Kleen

Brendon is an Editorial Lead at Awful Announcing overseeing digital content and special projects. He lives in Phoenix and has covered sports media for Awful Announcing since 2023.

Brendon writes the Awful Announcing 'The A Block' newsletter every Monday Subscribe here.