Dave Portnoy insists Barstool Sports isn’t being run by “woke overlords” amid concerns over a bubbling rift between him and Penn Entertainment. And while that may very well be true, there most certainly appears to be a rift between the Barstool Sports founder and a now former employee.
On Monday, Portnoy announced the departure of another Barstool personality.
This is the second instance of Portnoy doing so in the past few months, but this time around, it doesn’t appear that his hand was forced by the parent company. On Monday’s edition of Barstool Rundown, Portnoy announced that the “wild, tumultuous career of Jeff Nadu is over at Barstool.”
The wild tumultuous career of Jeff Nadu is over at Barstool https://t.co/JwTLhRkbXI pic.twitter.com/1rffbMQS3x
— Dave Portnoy (@stoolpresidente) June 5, 2023
Last week, Portnoy announced he was hiring former Barstool personality Ben Mintz as the first employee of his Brick Watch Company. The hire came less than one month after Penn Entertainment fired Mintz from Barstool Sports for saying a racial slur while reading a song lyric during a live stream.
It doesn’t appear that like Mintz, Nadu will ever be back in any capacity. Portnoy insisted that he harbored no “ill will” towards Nadu before saying that if he saw him get hit by a car, he would not stop to call an ambulance or help him up.
“Not because I hate him,” Portnoy explained. “Because there’s nobody who’s just more for himself and dumb. And it’s like, I can’t risk getting a fingernail broken pressing 9-1-1… Again, I don’t hate him. I don’t.”
Portnoy maintained that when Barstool let Nadu back into the company, he signed a two-year deal with the company. Nadu had previously quit and according to Portnoy, “begged” to come back to Barstool. The deal, as Portnoy goes on to explain, was a one-year deal with an option for a second year.
“I think we gave him about a $10,000 raise,” Portnoy said. “He says, ‘I expected my contract to be doubled.’ I think he wanted $200,000 a year.”
“I’m like, ‘You signed a contract. You fulfill your contract, and at the end of your contract we’ll discuss what you want,’” he added.
Portnoy said that Barstool is not in the business of handing out 100% raises, so they were more than happy to let Nadu walk. It also was revealed that Barstool does not make money off of Nadu’s The Sit Down: A Crime History Podcast. Portnoy said that Nadu’s podcast did “OK,” so, there was no real reason for him to be seeking a raise of that magnitude.
“He’s the most ungrateful, selfish pig I’ve ever met probably, really,” Portnoy said.
Nadu responded to Portnoy’s comments on Twitter, saying that he was betting on himself amidst retweeting tweets of support:
A lot of people think they know but in the end I will bet on myself any day. You can hate on me and think you know but very few would do what I did. Keep saying I can’t
— BIG MAN ON CAMPUS (@JeffNadu) June 6, 2023
Whether Portnoy was joking or not, Katz said he thought Nadu could be back. It didn’t take long for the kibosh to be put on that idea.
“No, no, he’s dead, Dan,” Portnoy added. “Dan, he’s dead. I can’t deal with this guy anymore…He’s the most narcissistic person in the world, and that’s saying a lot.”
[Barstool Rundown; photo from Matt Stone/Courier Journal/USA TODAY NETWORK]

About Sam Neumann
Sam joined Awful Announcing and The Comeback as a staff writer at the beginning of 2023 and now serves as a senior editor. A 2021 graduate of Temple University, Sam is a Charlotte native who now calls Greenville, South Carolina home. He also has a love/hate relationship with the New York Mets and Jets.
Sam writes the Awful Announcing 'The A Block' newsletter every Tuesday Subscribe here.
Recent Posts
Skip Bayless dismisses Troy Aikman being able to work with Jerry Jones: ‘He would be a threat’
"He just doesn’t want a threat. Troy would be a threat."
Jeremy Fowler signs new multiyear deal with ESPN, expands role onto NFL Network
The longtime ESPN insider will add NFL Live, Good Morning Football, and The Aftermath to his television workload.
Lisa Salters praised for awareness in deferring sideline report
"This is how it's done."
Steelers radio analyst Max Starks drove 15 hours to Cincinnati after nationwide ground stop
"It's Steelers-Bungles week! For the love of the game!"
Scott Van Pelt knew he jinxed the Ravens with unanimous picks
"You know what this means, everybody, you're going to save it, you're going to run it in our face on social media."
Joe Tessitore, Dan Orlovsky return to call Overtime’s high school football national championship on ESPN2
The second edition of Overtime and Omaha Productions’ high school title game adds $300,000 in donations to the schools.