He’s brash. He’s bold. And he’s head of ESPN’s Scouts, Inc., but that doesn’t stop people from within the football community from questioning his credentials and expertise. The latest is agent Leigh Steinberg whose client is quarterback Paxton Lynch.
During a media conference call earlier this week, McShay said Lynch played in a very simplistic offense at Memphis and added, “He’s got to learn how to get his team in and out of a huddle, and how to make line checks, and pre-snap audibles, and get them out of bad plays into good plays — he hasn’t had to do any of those things.”
That led Steinberg to go on a Twitter rant:
#NFLDraft Everyone entitled to opinion,but Todd McShay's vitriolic assessment of @PaxtonLynch's ability is absurd.Doesn't work for a team!
— Leigh Steinberg (@leighsteinberg) April 21, 2016
#NFLDraft Hope public knows that Todd McShay,self-proclaimed draft guru never played,coached,scouted in college or NFL.@ESPN @PaxtonLynch
— Leigh Steinberg (@leighsteinberg) April 21, 2016
That’s a little below the belt there. As much as McShay is disliked by certain people, there’s no need to bring up his background. For what it’s worth, McShay did play in college as a backup quarterback at Richmond College and also was an undergraduate assistant for the school, but it doesn’t mean that he’s not qualified to be a draft expert.
Steinberg later regretted his tweet:
#NFLDraft Everyone is entitled to their opinion,I regret responding to McShay's toxic assessment of Paxton by bringing up his background.
— Leigh Steinberg (@leighsteinberg) April 22, 2016
But Steinberg is not alone in his opinion on McShay. Pro Football Talk asked a long-time NFL scout if teams pay attention to what McShay says and said fellow ESPN draftnik Mel Kiper, Jr. has more respect … “And that’s a stretch, too.”
Steinberg went public with his assessment of McShay and it probably mirrors what many agents, scouts and executives feels, however, it appears he’s going to be with ESPN for a long time to come so the NFL community had better get used to his opinions.

Comments are closed.
About Ken Fang
Ken has been covering the sports media in earnest at his own site, Fang's Bites since May 2007 and at Awful Announcing since March 2013.
He provides a unique perspective having been an award-winning radio news reporter in Providence and having worked in local television.
Fang celebrates the four Boston Red Sox World Championships in the 21st Century, but continues to be a long-suffering Cleveland Browns fan.
Recent Posts
Gilbert Arenas signs with Playmaker after ugly split from Underdog
The relaunched "Gil's Arena" will return daily starting in August.
Golf Channel goes all-in covering Bryson DeChambeau drama at Open Championship
"It is really hard to stomach the silliness that we've seen here from Bryson... Childish."
Fox’s John Strong: ‘Fun, unique thing’ for Trump to appear at World Cup final; ‘my job is to play it down the middle’
"Certainly when it comes to President Trump, there are no neutral opinions."
Jeff Pearlman apologizes after YouTuber catches him plagiarizing video on former Yankees phenom
"We're just going to strive to do a lot better."
Texas Rangers fans demand refunds after abrupt move to new streaming platform
Rangers Sports Media and Entertainment Company chairman Neil Leibman is also a director at BZZR.
Top execs from Fox Sports, ESPN express strong interest in future World Cup rights
FIFA is expected to package English and Spanish-language rights, with a reported asking price of at least $1.5 billion annually.