Jose Quintana

There are plenty of online forums full of trade rumors, but it’s surprising when one turns out not only to be accurate, but to be the first source of information on a story. That’s what happened on r/whitesox (the Reddit subreddit dedicated to the Chicago White Sox) Wednesday night, though, with users KatyPerrysBootyHole and WetButt23 discussing the Jose Quintana trade to the cross-town Cubs for four prospects long before it happened, while media reports only came out after the trade was announced by the team. Here’s the start of the Reddit users’ conversation, as screenshotted by SB Nation’s Grant Brisbee:

There were then follow-up posts with more details:

Quintana follow-up

This all came out before anyone in the media got it, leading to a really amusing correction to J.J. Stankevitz’s CSN Chicago piece on how secretive these teams were:

…That nobody was able to get anything out about this story until both teams announced the trade is what’s maybe the most surprising thing about Thursday’s crosstown blockbuster. The news broke by the White Sox and Cubs both sending tweets and press releases.

…In today’s digital age, it’s rare — maybe even unprecedented — for a trade of this magnitude to fly under the radar until it’s finalized and announced. But the White Sox and Cubs managed to do just that while pulling off a trade that could alter the landscape of baseball in this city for the next decade.

Correction: While no national media had this story, a Reddit user named “wetbutt23” had it last night. CSNChicago.com apologizes to wetbutt23 for the error.

But ESPN’s piece had no mentions of the Reddit sleuths, and their Bottom Line ticker sadly didn’t credit anyone; it would have been something to see “first reported by KatyPerrysBootyHole and wetbutt23 there.” It’s not a real ESPN sourcing controversy (which they’ve been much better about in recent years), but it is funny that other media outlets will mention this and they won’t. Maybe it’s for the best, though, given some of what you can find in these users’ Reddit histories, especially when it comes to a thread of “What is the most offensive joke in your arsenal?”, a discussion of third-wave feminism, and a discussion of the Big Bang theory (not the show) being proposed by a Catholic priest:

Reddit butts comments.

We regret to inform you that anonymous accounts named after butts don’t just break trades, they also sometimes make problematic internet comments.

[Grant Brisbee on Twitter]

About Andrew Bucholtz

Andrew Bucholtz is a staff writer for Awful Announcing.

  • PAI

    Queue AA’s character assassination of 2 Reddit users in 3… 2… 1…

    The wetbutt guy is a tad over the line, the other is spouting complete common sense.

  • 3D

    The more I see of this, the more I love it. The major media outlets fall all over themselves to be the first to get stuff and they get it spectacularly wrong (see the Wilmer Flores non-trade of 2015). Every organization uses that zeal to be the first on any given story, and plays these reporters as dupes to leak things they want put into the water.

    “Rando reddit guy” doesn’t share that dynamic, and so real news will frequently leak through “so and so told me” in a way that can’t happen through ESPN or whatever. Making these bloated middlemen more and more irrelevant.

  • Pingback: CSN Chicago's David Kaplan falls for fake Sonny Gray rumor, then refuses to take the L()